seafood logo
Market - 631.537.0633
Catering - click here

Take Out Menu

STARTERS
Peconic Bay Oysters | black pepper, mignonette ▪ fresh lemon (6pcs)
Local Little Neck Clams | house-made cocktail sauce ▪ fresh lemon (6pcs)
Shrimp Cocktail | house-made cocktail sauce ▪ fresh lemon (6pcs)
Local Steamers | white wine ▪ garlic ▪ butter ▪ fresh parsley
PEI Mussels (1lb) | white wine ▪ garlic ▪ butter ▪ fresh parsley 

SALADS
(top our house or caesar with any seafood for an additional charge)
House Salad | organic mixed greens ▪ red onions ▪ cucumbers ▪ tomato ▪ shredded carrot ▪ house vinaigrette
Caesar Salad | romaine ▪ grated parmesan ▪ seasoned croutons ▪ onion ▪ house-made garlic, anchovy dressing
Seared Tuna | organic mixed greens ▪ cucumber ▪ tomatoes ▪ carrots ▪ crispy wontons ▪ miso citrus dressing
Chopped Chicken & Apple | romaine ▪ grilled chicken ▪ crumbled bleu ▪ white balsamic vinaigrette


SFS FAVORITES
(choice of two sides)
Fish & Chips | fresh flounder ▪ waffle fries ▪ house-made tartar ▪ coleslaw
Fried Shrimp Platter | medium shrimp ▪ lemon ▪ house-made tartar sauce
Fried Lump Crab Cakes | two cakes ▪ fresh lemon ▪ chipotle mayo
Fish Tacos (grilled or fried) | tilapia ▪ pickled cabbage ▪ mango salsa ▪ spicy crema
Grilled Tuna Steak | cooked to temperature ▪ horseradish mayo ▪ fresh lemon
Lobster Dinner | pick your weight ▪ steamed to order ▪ fresh lemon ▪ melted butter MKT.
Fried Calamari | tartar sauce ▪ lemon
Super Combo (fried) | flounder ▪ shrimp ▪ clams ▪ sea scallops
Grilled Salmon Fillet | house-made dill mayo ▪ fresh lemon
Grilled Sea Scallops | horseradish mayo ▪ fresh lemon
Grilled Swordfish| horseradish mayo ▪ fresh lemon

SANDWICHES
(All sandwiches come w/ choice of two sides)
Fried Fish-wich | flounder ▪ lettuce ▪ tomato ▪ tartar ▪ brioche burger bun
Shrimp & Oyster “Po Boy” | cornmeal crust ▪ lettuce ▪ tomato ▪ spicy remoulade
Crispy Chipotle Chicken | apple -smoked bacon ▪ lettuce ▪ tomato ▪ cheddar ▪ chipotle mayo ▪ brioche bun
Tuna Salad | fresh caught tuna ▪ mayo ▪ celery ▪ onion ▪ lettuce ▪ tomato ▪ brioche bun
Grilled Salmon Burger | sweet soy ▪ grilled red onion ▪ brioche bun
Lobster Roll | chilled lobster salad ▪ potato hot dog roll
The Crab “Bahn Mi” | lump crab cake ▪ jalapeno ▪ pickled vegetables ▪ cucumber ▪ sweet chili mayo


LOBSTERS IN THE ROUGH
(come with melted butter & lemon)
Steamed 1 1/4 lb Lobster | MKT.
Steamed 1 1/2 lb Lobster | MKT
Steamed 2 lb Lobster | MKT.
(All Lobsters Come Cracked & Split)


SIDES
Spanish Rice
Spicy Waffle Fries
Coleslaw
Onion Rings
Grilled Seasonal Vegetables 


Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish & eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness,
especially if you have certain medical conditions.
All prices and menu items are subject to change without notice due to market & season.
Any fish from our case (whole fish icluded) can be appropriately cooked for
Minimum cooking fee up to one lb of fish with choice of two sides.

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Freshest Fish, The Finest Choice - 40 Years & Thriving!